Sunlit ivory stucco entry with a bronze glazed door, limestone steps and a mature sea grape beside the porch.

St. Armands Circle Played Musical Chairs After the Storms. Here's Where Everyone Landed.

November 5, 2026

Since the 2024 hurricanes, most of St. Armands Circle's new names have moved into older buildings. Tommy Bahama now operates out of the building that used to be Shore. Pinchers is the seafood restaurant headed for the corner Tommy Bahama held for nearly 30 years. The dining room where Le Colonne served for more than 25 years is now Nonno Umberto, run by the founder's son.

That's a useful thing to know before your next dinner on the Circle or the next time you bring guests from out of town. Your old landmark may still be standing but now be home to someone else. In the meantime, the one restaurateur trying to put up a new building on the Circle has spent the fall in city review.

Follow the addresses

Each of these addresses changed hands or went dark after the storms:

  1. 465 John Ringling Blvd. Shore closed its St. Armands location here after the 2024 hurricanes. Restaurateur Tom Leonard still owns the building and leases it to Tommy Bahama, which held its grand reopening there in November 2025.
  2. 300 John Ringling Blvd. Tommy Bahama's home of nearly 30 years opened up when storm damage pushed the brand to 465. Pinchers, a 200-seat seafood restaurant, is the next tenant here. It will be the 11th Gulf Coast location for Naples-based Phelan Family Brands, which also runs a Pinchers on Lakewood Ranch Main Street.
  3. 22 S. Boulevard of the Presidents. Le Colonne opened here in 1998. After the 2024 hurricanes, owner Umberto Salustri decided to close. His son Simone Salustri and Amber Mayner began renovating in September 2025 and opened Nonno Umberto, an Italian seafood restaurant and steakhouse, in December 2025. Nonno is Italian for grandfather.
  4. 29 N. Boulevard of the Presidents. Speaks Clam Bar served its last day here on March 15, 2026. Its Lakewood Ranch location is still open.

Your Observer still counts more than a dozen restaurants on the Circle. Several of them are simply sitting at different addresses than they were two years ago.

The anchor that came back first

Columbia Restaurant is the fixed point on this map. It opened its Cuban-Spanish restaurant on the Circle in 1959. Your Observer reported that Columbia and Cha Cha Coconuts reopened after storm repairs on Saturday, Oct. 26, 2024, weeks after Milton. Columbia's St. Armands page lists the location's current hours.

So the oldest dining room on the Circle came back quickly at its original address. Most of what followed came back at different addresses.

South Boulevard of the Presidents became the new-tenant block

Put the openings of the past year on a map and most of them sit within a few doors of each other on South Boulevard of the Presidents.

Nonno Umberto, 22 S. Boulevard of the Presidents. The couple modernized the 300-seat room with a coastal feel and wrote what they call an elevated, contemporary menu based on Simone Salustri's roots in a coastal Italian town. Mayner told Your Observer that the best sellers are the whole bronzino, which the chef debones, the dry-aged meat and the shrimp cocktail. The kitchen bakes its own bread and desserts, and shrimp carpaccio was a recent addition.

"Our summer was absolutely amazing. We can't believe how busy we were."

Mayner said that to Your Observer in a mid-September interview, after the restaurant's first summer.

Chocolate Emporium, 28 S. Boulevard of the Presidents. This artisanal chocolate shop had its soft opening at the end of June 2026, and the Circle Association's ice cream and confections directory lists it at this address. Your Observer covered the opening that same week.

Flambo, 40 S. Boulevard of the Presidents. Flambo serves Trinidadian food. It soft-opened in October 2025 and held its grand opening that November, so it reaches its first anniversary this month. Co-owner Anthony Logan, who runs the 175-seat restaurant with his son Kevin Ramlochan, told Your Observer that butter chicken in a mildly spiced tomato cream sauce is the top seller. The Flambo red snapper with pickled vegetables comes next, then the Trini drunken rice noodles.

Rachel Burns, executive director of the St. Armands Circle Association, told the Observer that more boutique-style eateries and businesses are on the way, including a coffee and dessert shop. She described the Circle's approach as variety. "There's a lot of opportunity for small restaurant owners to find a niche for something original," she told Your Observer.

Burns also explained the reasoning behind Pinchers. Florida seafood is one of the requests she hears most from visitors. "They want to experience the Florida that they're seeing on TV," she said, describing a "relaxed, upscale vibe where you're dressed up, but you're still wearing your flip-flops."

The one new building is the one still waiting

Reusing an existing space has been the quickest way back onto the Circle. Shore's return shows what happens when an owner tries to build something different.

Leonard and the Kaufman development family have proposed rebuilding a two-story gutted shell at the corner of Boulevard of the Presidents and Madison Drive. The plan puts a boutique shop and casual cafe on the ground floor, the Shore restaurant on the second floor and a residential level on the third, according to Your Observer's Oct. 21 report. That report says the third floor will likely be left unfinished at first.

At the city's Development Review Committee meeting on Oct. 7, the resubmitted plan ran into two code interpretations:

  • Flood-proofing and height. The team plans to spend more than $200,000 dry-proofing the street level with aquarium glass rated for high water. In the Commercial Tourism zone, the city's only district of its kind, dry-proofing caps building height at 35 feet. Wet-proofing, which lets water flow beneath occupied space, allows 45 feet for residential structures.
  • The balcony. The plan includes a second-floor dining balcony over the sidewalk. City staff are applying the same rule they use for awnings, and neither is allowed to extend past the property line.

Project consultant Bill Waddill of Kimley-Horn told the Observer the height rule works against investing in resilience on St. Armands. A city spokesperson said the next step is for the applicant to resubmit and that staff expect to talk through the concerns with the applicant before then.

That puts the three reused addresses and the Shore proposal on different clocks. A tenant moving into an existing room can renovate and open within months, the way Nonno Umberto did between September and December 2025. Shore's plan is still waiting on its next resubmittal.

Where the season's events meet the new map

The Circle's event calendar hasn't changed. What sits around each event has. The St. Armands Circle Association lists the following dates through mid-December 2026:

Date Event Hours Sponsor listed
Sat.–Sun., Nov. 14–15 St. Armands Circle Art Festival & Sidewalk Sale 10 a.m.–5 p.m. ArtFestival.com
Fri., Dec. 4 48th Annual Holiday Night of Lights 5:30–8 p.m. St. Armands Circle Association
Sat., Dec. 12 22nd Annual Porsches in the Park 9 a.m.–2 p.m. Suncoast Motorsports

The Nov. 14–15 art festival uses St. Armands Circle Park and South Boulevard of the Presidents, the same block as Nonno Umberto, Chocolate Emporium and Flambo. Festival visitors who have not been on the Circle since 2024 will find a different set of restaurants along those booths.

The Holiday Night of Lights reaches its 48th year on Dec. 4, and the association says the evening "will magically transform St. Armands Circle into your favorite Holiday destination on the Gulf Coast of Florida." Eight days later, Porsches in the Park returns for its 22nd year, with cars from around Florida displayed in St. Armands Circle Park.

For an evening that covers the new map, start with chocolate at 28 S. Boulevard of the Presidents. Walk a few doors to Flambo or Nonno Umberto for dinner. On the way back to your car, pass 465 John Ringling, which is still Shore's building, now with Tommy Bahama inside. On Dec. 4, the Night of Lights runs from 5:30 to 8 p.m., so that same walk happens with the Circle lit for the holidays.

Storms don't only change the restaurants. They also change how a neighborhood's homes are valued. If you own near the Circle, on Lido or anywhere along Sarasota's barrier islands and want to know how the past two years show up in your home's numbers, Angie Richison can build that picture for your address. Request a free market analysis, and Angie will walk you through what nearby homes have sold for since the storms and what that means for yours.

Ready When You Are

Experience a data-driven, relationship-focused approach to real estate designed around your success.